2021 NATIONAL CONVENTION (October16, 2021)

Reform Party National CommitteeReform Party National Committee

  • OUR PARTY
  • SOLUTIONS
  • GET INVOLVED
  • CONTRIBUTE
Com Com
Sunday, July 10, 2022 / Published in Uncategorized

Of Vouchers, Education, and Entitlements

“Another example of the educational inequality is the current debate over publicly financed school vouchers which will provide educational opportunities to a privileged handful but deprive public schools of desperately needed resources.”- Bobby Scott (Representative, Virginia)

“And before our current legislature adjourns, we intend to become the first state of full and true choice by saying to every low and middle-income Hoosier family, if you think a non-government school is the right one for your child, you’re as entitled to that option as any wealthy family; here’s a voucher, go sign up.” Mitch Daniels (Indiana Governor 2005-2013)

These two quotes represent the battle lines in the voucher debate. One purports that taking tax dollars away from public schools for private ones will harm public education. The other purports to give equal opportunity for poor people to access better education. 

The hope on one side is that given enough time and money, ALL public schools can provide a good education. On the other side, the hope is that vouchers will threaten public schools’ existence, and thereby the competition will cause poor school systems to improve.

Indiana Choice Scholarship Participation

In Indiana, a school voucher study has shown: “Our research also indicates that voucher students begin to recoup their academic losses in their third and fourth years of attending a private school. Students transitioning to a private school may need time to acclimate to what are usually more rigorous academic standards and higher expectations for homework and schoolwork.”- Indiana’s Choice Scholarship: Participation & Impact on Achievement.

In Washington DC voucher schools, academic results demonstrated: “In short, the best evidence available to this point shows that in terms of the test score measures emphasized by advocates and incorporated in the legislation, there are no significant net benefits from the effort even though families who chose and followed through over the years are likely to be strongly committed.”

In New York City, evidence exists that reducing the size of school populations significantly impacted graduation rates. “New York City pursued a policy in 2002 that “closed many large, comprehensive high schools with a history of low performance” and opened hundreds of small secondary schools of choice. This was not without controversy, but research has shown that the program “markedly increased high school graduation rates for large numbers of disadvantaged students of color” as more students earned the rigorous Regents diploma.” – Center for American Progress.  

While the two political sides continue to advocate their positions with many examples and conclusions, the fundamental issue comes down to “what does an American citizen expect from an educational system?”

Is it a surprise that different segments of society have different expectations of public education? Is it a surprise to anyone that the purpose of public education is to provide the community and society with a pool of young adults with enough education to fill jobs available in business and industry? Is it a further surprise to anyone that school boards are local, so local authorities can make decisions to serve the people within the school district?

Everyone thinks what is good for them is also suitable for everyone else. Local school boards sort out the needs of the community, society, and educators and produce a hybrid educational system that aligns with the population at large. The educational needs of families in rural and remote areas are far different than those who live in major urban areas. School districts reflect those differences. Not all school districts serve the educational needs of children in the same manner.

One-size-fits-all is a terrible tool to impose upon the educational system. The Trump-DeVos Voucher Plan is a plan that would not work in rural and remote areas of the United States.

For example:

“Hot Springs County School District #1 in Thermopolis, Wyoming, for example, has a total of 650 students attending the district’s one elementary school, one middle school, and one high school. It is the only school district in Hot Springs County, Wyoming, with the closest school located in another district more than 30 miles away. It serves the county of Hot Springs, which covers more than 2,000 square miles. There are no general education private schools or charter schools in the county, and the state of Wyoming does not have a voucher program.”

Echoing voices of other rural areas, the lack of private and public schools in some districts provides no voucher choice at all for families. Yet, there does appear to be a role for the federal and state governments to play in public education beyond the simple allocation of funds.

The need is tools for schools. School boards should strive to focus on quality education for all students and acquire tools to provide a better education.

Quality education has become an entitlement for American families. So has a safe learning environment.

What will the future of K-12 education look like? It’s still developing, but it appears to be a future that begins in metro areas and then spreads to rural and remote areas.

Let’s work on the future education of our citizens. The future is a collaborative effort, and no one has the ultimate solution. Let’s find a way to increase the skills and education of all students through federal and state tools to local schools boards regardless of their location.

An informed and educated population makes America a better country.

Quality Education Everywhere must become the principal driver in American education.

Com Com

See author's posts

What you can read next

Reform Party Seeks to Fill National, State Vacancies
The House Healthcare Bill is Political Theater
Misery, Money, and the Working Class
The History of Black History Month

Latest Posts from Insights and Action

  • Kentucky Flood Illustrates Larger Issues with Infrastructure and Poverty

    The Reform Party skims the surface of infrastru...
  • Reform Party Announces Public Interest Meeting on July 26th, at 9pm EST

    The Reform Party of the United States is having...
  • Honoring and Celebrating the Fourth of July

    It’s difficult today to remember the stru...

SEARCH

RECENT POSTS

  • Kentucky Flood Illustrates Larger Issues with Infrastructure and Poverty

  • Reform Party Announces Public Interest Meeting on July 26th, at 9pm EST

  • Honoring and Celebrating the Fourth of July

TAG CLOUD

Ben Zion Budget Reform Congress Congressman John Lewis (D-GA) Coronavirus COVID Immigration Infrastructure Insurance Cost Share Irish Jack Achenbach for Congress Kentucky Max Abramson Michael Hackmer Military Spending Nicholas Hensley Reform Reform Party Roque "Rocky" de la Fuente Roque “Rocky” de la Fuente ross perot Russia Shawn Storm small business Souraya Faas Spending Two-Party System ukraine War Crimes

Ballot Access Drives

Support Candidate Ballot Access

Support Candidate Ballot Access
Our candidates need help to get the signatures required to run for office. Click here to join our effort.

Connect On Social Media

Connect with us online

Reform Party on Social Media
The Reform Party is growing its social media presence everyday through Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and more. Click here to connect with us online.

Upcoming Events

Meet Reformers at local events

Reform Party Events
The Reform Party is holding activities and events in districts all across the country and online. Click here to see upcoming events.

Our Solutions

  • Election Reform
  • Government and Ethics
  • Fiscal Responsibility
  • Economy and Job Market
  • Energy and Environmental Practices
  • Tax Policy
  • National Security
  • Foreign Policy
  • Constitutional Rights
  • Personal Healthcare
  • Education
  • Social Issues
  • Legislative Processes and Lobbying
  • Reduce Government Overreach and Size
  • Reform Justice and Penal Systems

Resources

  • Core Principles
  • National Chairman’s Message
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Reform Party Store
  • National Debt Clock
  • Research and eBooks
  • Events and Webinars
  • Insights and Action

Take Action

  • Get Involved
  • Join the Reform Party
  • Become A Candidate
  • Contribute / Donate
  • Courses and Training

Key Contacts

  • Reform Party Chairman’s Office
  • National Committee
  • Contact Your State Leaders
  • Press and Media Relations
  • Our Social Media Channels

Reform Party National Committee

Nicholas Hensley, Chairman
Leigh Pollet, Vice-chairman of Operations
David Collison, Treasurer
Shawn Storm, Secretary

Mailing Address
Reform Party of the United States
PO Box 660675 #3995
Dallas, TX 75266-0675

© Copyright 2021 All Rights Reserved - Privacy Policy

By providing your phone number, you are consenting to receive calls and SMS/MMS msgs, including autodialed and automated calls and texts, to that number from the Reform Party National Committee. Msg&data rates may apply.

Paid for by the Reform Party National Committee. Not Authorized By Any Candidate Or Candidate's Committee. www.reformparty.org

TOP